Set the oven to 350°F. Butter the inside of a 3-quart or 9×13-inch casserole dish, then keep it nearby for assembling the casserole.
Fill a large pot with water and bring it to a boil over high heat. Add 1 Tbsp of the salt, followed by the macaroni. Cook according to the package instructions until al dente. Scoop out 1/2 cup of the pasta cooking water before draining. Once drained, toss the pasta immediately with the oil so it does not stick together, then set it aside.
Place the cheddar and mozzarella in a large bowl and mix them together. The combined cheeses should total about 8 cups. Set aside.
Melt the butter over medium heat in a 5 1/2-quart Dutch oven or large pot. When the butter starts to foam, whisk in the flour. Cook while whisking for approximately 2 minutes, stopping when the flour is beginning to take on a pale golden color.
Without stopping the whisking, slowly add the milk, heavy cream, and reserved pasta water. Continue until the mixture becomes smooth and creamy with no flour lumps and is just beginning to boil.
Add the paprika, mustard powder, garlic powder, onion powder, the remaining 1/2 teaspoon of salt, and the black pepper. Turn the heat down to low. Simmer for 2 to 3 minutes, whisking continuously, until the sauce reaches a light gravy-like thickness.
Mix 3 cups of the cheese mixture into the sauce and stir until melted. Follow with another 3 cups of cheese, again stirring until fully melted. Keep the final 2 cups aside for the top. Fold the cooked macaroni into the sauce until evenly coated. Remove the pot from the heat, taste, and season with additional salt and pepper if needed.
Spoon the macaroni mixture into the prepared casserole dish and spread it evenly. Cover the surface with the remaining 2 cups of cheese. Bake for 15 minutes, until the topping has melted and is bubbling. If you want additional browning, change the oven setting to broil for the final 2 to 3 minutes. Serve while warm.